Medicare Handbook Controversy


Medicare’s 2007 handbook "Medicare and You 2007" was recently mailed to all Medicare beneficiaries. The guide is intended to be a resource for beneficiaries, providing impartial information enabling subscribers to evaluate and compare health care plans.

In a letter to Michael Leavitt, Secretary of Health & Human Services, leading Democrats charged the publication "presents a misleading and biased view of Medicare coverage options." The letter went on to say, "The 2007 handbook strongly favors health maintenance organizations, preferred provider organizations and other private Medicare Advantage plans over the traditional Medicare fee-for-service program."

William Dombi, Vice President of the National Association for Home Care also expressed concern about misleading information in the handbook, stating, "Many home health agencies have found that they can deliver more care, and more effective care, to patients in traditional Medicare than to those in Medicare Advantage plans." Citing one specific example, Mr. Dombi said traditional Medicare does not charge co-pays for home care whereas some private Medicare plans may charge co-pays of $20 to $35 for each visit.

A spokesperson for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Lorraine Ryan, responded, "Our only goal is to provide information that is accurate, useful and objective." The Bush administration supported the handbook and touted the notable savings (reportedly more than an average of $100 per month) beneficiaries could receive by subscribing to private plans.

Source:, 10-29-06

Give Us A Call



Recent Articles

What to Know About Creating a Living Will

Creating a living will ensures your future health care decisions and plans are respected. A living will, or advance directive, is a legal document outlining medical treatment preferences and end-of-life care if you can’t communicate or make decisions for yourself.

Read More >

Why Hire an Elder Law Attorney?

Elder law attorneys may specialize in estate planning, incapacity planning, and end-of-life care for seniors. They also help older adults remain in their homes as they age and protect them from abuse. These practitioners are essential because they work to

Read More >

Get The Answers You Need.

Free Situation Intake

Note: This is not the MassHealth website. We are a private law firm.

Tell Us Your Story

Note: This is not the MassHealth website. We are a private law firm.